Introduction

In the world of Lean Six Sigma, the difference between success and mediocrity often hinges on the projects we choose to embark on. The process of project scoring and ranking stands as a cornerstone in this decision-making process, ensuring that Lean Six Sigma initiatives are not just well-executed but are also the right fit for the organization’s goals.

​

The Essence of Project Selection in Lean Six Sigma

Selecting the right project is like setting the sails in the right direction for a voyage. It’s about aligning resources, efforts, and strategic objectives to navigate towards maximum efficiency and impactful results. 

The Nuances of Project Scoring and Ranking

At its core, project scoring and ranking is an evaluative process that sifts through potential projects to identify those that promise the most significant impact. This process is less about ticking boxes and more about understanding and aligning with the broader organizational vision.

​

Unpacking the Process

Criteria Development

• The foundation of effective project selection lies in defining what matters. Criteria can range from potential benefits and resource availability to strategic alignment and customer impact. The key is to capture the essence of what will drive value for the business.

Scoring Mechanism

• Each project is scored against these criteria. However, this isn’t just about numbers; it’s about understanding the potential impact of a project in tangible and intangible terms.

Prioritization through Weighting

• Not all criteria carry equal weight. This stage is about recognizing which aspects of the project align most closely with strategic priorities and giving them the emphasis they deserve.

Holistic Evaluation

• By combining scores and weights, each project is given a comprehensive evaluation. This total score is more than a number – it’s a reflection of the project’s potential value to the organization.

Ranking for Decision-Making

• Projects are then ranked, but this is not a mere listing. It’s a strategic exercise in understanding where to allocate resources for optimal impact. 
  

Tools and Techniques: Beyond the Basics

While tools like the Decision Matrix and Analytic Hierarchy Process offer structured approaches, and Cost-Benefit Analysis provides a financial perspective, the art of project scoring and ranking transcends these tools. It’s about a nuanced understanding of what each project can bring to the table.

Best Practices: A Holistic Approach

Inclusive Stakeholder Engagement

• The best scoring and ranking processes draw on diverse perspectives. Involving stakeholders from various departments ensures a more rounded view of each project’s potential.

Adaptive Reassessment

• Business needs evolve, and so should our project priorities. Regular reassessment of projects ensures that the organization remains agile and responsive to change.

Transparent Processes

• Clarity and openness in how projects are scored and ranked foster trust and ensure buy-in across the organization. 
  

Conclusion

In Lean Six Sigma, choosing the right project is as important as executing it well. Project scoring and ranking is an art that balances quantitative evaluation with a qualitative understanding of an organization’s strategic needs. It’s a process that ensures not just operational efficiency, but strategic efficacy in the continuous journey towards excellence.